Land Stewardship Project

Land Stewardship Project
  • About Us
    • Our Mission
    • Long Range Plan
    • Staff Directory
    • Board of Directors
    • Contact Us
    • Past LSP Projects
    • Employment & Volunteer Opportunities
    • LSP Publications
  • The Latest
    • 40th Anniversary Events
    • Tell us an LSP Story
    • Songs for the Soil
    • CSA Farm Directory
    • Upcoming Events
    • News
      • News Releases
      • Media Contacts
      • LSP in the News
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    • Land Stewardship Letter
    • LIVE-WIRE Sign-up
    • Myth Busters
    • Fact Sheets
    • Farm Crisis Resources
  • For Farmers & Landowners
    • New Farmers
      • Farm Beginnings Class
      • Journeyperson Course
      • Farm Dreams Workshop
      • Farmland Clearinghouse
      • Accessing Farmland
      • Beginning/Retiring Farmer Tax Credit
      • Beginning Farmer Profiles
    • Retiring Farmers & Landowners
      • Farmland Clearinghouse
      • Conservation Leases
      • Beginning/Retiring Farmer Tax Credit
      • Land Transition Tools
      • Transition Stories
    • Soil Health
      • Cover Crops
      • Grazing
      • No-till
      • Microbiology
      • Soil Builders’ Network
      • Soil Builders’ E-Letters
    • Cropping Systems Calculator
    • Conservation Leases
  • Creating Change
    • Community-Based Food Systems
      • Community Food Webs Learning Circles
    • Policy Campaigns
      • Soil Health & Climate Change
      • Healthcare
      • Factory Farms
      • Federal Policy
        • A Farm Bill For Us
      • State Policy
      • Developing Leadership
      • Caucus for Land Stewardship
    • Justice & Stewardship
    • Organizational Stewardship
    • Building People Power
  • Get Involved
    • Take Action!
    • Upcoming Events
    • Land Stewardship Action Fund
    • Connect with LSP
      • Stay Connected
      • Join, Donate, or Renew Today!
      • Shop
      • Employment & Volunteer Opportunities
      • Legacy Giving
    • Network with LSP Members
      • Farmland Clearinghouse
      • Soil Health
  • Join, Donate, or Renew Today!
  • Stay Connected
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
Search
More...

Line 3 Environmental Damage & State Regulatory Failure

It's Now Clear Approval of the Pipeline Failed the Land, Our Water & People

By John King
January 12, 2023

Share

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • email

Note: The Land Stewardship Project’s current long-range plan outlines why we cannot have a sustainable society while we rely on a system focused on extractive fossil fuels. In the plan, LSP promises to “advance solutions to the climate crisis by innovating and promoting resilient, soil-building farming systems and moving our society away from a reliance on fossil fuels.” It has become clear that the Enbridge Line 3 tar sands oil pipeline in northern Minnesota does not advance solutions to the climate crisis and deepens our dependence on fossil fuels. And as this blog by LSP member John King documents, it is also a major threat to the region’s water quality and environmental health in general. For more information on this issue, see the bottom of this blog.

♦ ♦ ♦

Everybody should be happy.  The new Line 3 pipeline, traveling 337 miles through Minnesota and the biggest infrastructure project in state history, has been pushing Canadian tar sand oil through the region for over a year. At full capacity of 760,000 barrels a day, Enbridge, the Canadian builder and owner, would be raking in over $43 million a day. Over 200 law enforcement organizations collaborating with Enbridge for pipeline security divided up $8.5 million in payouts. That money was spent on body armor, surveillance drones, tear gas, batons, crowd control training, and wages. A dozen northern counties have pocketed $30 million in property tax revenue this year. That figure is expected to increase to $50 million next year.

Enbridge is especially happy. It got to do this to Minnesota with minimal regulatory oversight and a pittance in environmental fines. But above all, it got its pipeline, and without the pipeline the poor quality tar sands oil flowing through it would not have yielded much profit.

But everybody is not happy. Let’s put aside where this oil came from and how it was made. Let’s not talk about the thousands of acres of Alberta boreal forest  ripped up and bulldozed to the side to get at the oil-bearing sand. Let’s not talk about the 100-square-miles of sludge ponds leaching toxic chemicals into Alberta’s northern waterways. Let’s ignore the bargain basement quality of this tar sands oil that nobody really wants, and which uses almost as much energy to mine as it yields as a fuel. Let’s turn our backs on Alberta’s indigenous people who have used this land sustainably for thousands of years and which is now a foul-smelling strip mine. Let’s just talk about Minnesota.

A Legacy of Breaches

La Salle Creek is just a few miles north of Lake Itasca and its namesake state park. It is a tributary stream for the Mississippi River near its origin and borders the Headwaters State Forest. Along the way it flows into La Salle Lake, one of the deepest and most pristine lakes in the state. The lake hosts a State Recreation Area and a nearby Scenic and Natural Area. This water-rich ecosystem features a complex interchange between surface and subsurface water that sustains and enriches rare plants, endangered orchids, trout, old-growth cedar forests and an abundance of water-dependent creatures that require the cold, clear water of La Salle Creek. The area has been flagged by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources because of its unique and abundant biodiversity. It is a Minnesota gem, not much visited because of the more famous nearby state park.

In 2014, when the pipeline was being planned, expert witnesses warned that  “severe damage was likely in the La Salle Creek corridor” if pipeline construction were to occur there. “This area could well become a case study on where not to build a pipeline,” environmental expert Paul Stolen testified. Enbridge countered: “None of the data that were collected  suggest that a pipeline will adversely impact hydrologic conditions during and after construction.” State regulators, including the DNR and the Public Utilities Commissioners who had no pipeline experts of their own and were wishing the project to move forward with all due haste, issued their permits. Pipeline boosters cheered, saying that this was the most studied and well planned pipeline project in state history.

In August 2021, as they were trenching for the pipeline in the La Salle Creek corridor, Enbridge encountered an unanticipated amount of waterlogged peat and mud.  To counter the problem, construction crews drove sheet pilings deep into the ground, well below the 20-foot maximum depth allowed by their permit. The sheet pilings tore through the clay cap of the area’s aquifer, releasing what is estimated to be nearly 10 million gallons of water into the creek.

The “fix,” the remediation plan devised by Enbridge engineers, was a solid concrete wall 350-feet-long and extending 20 feet into the ground. This, they hoped, would stem the flow and save the creek and its wetlands. It did reduce the flow, but in at least a dozen places aquifer water continues to rise to the surface. This “new” water will change the chemistry of the creek and the “fix” will permanently alter the aquatic balance of the La Salle corridor ecosystem by interrupting the natural flow of the surface and subsurface water.

The La Salle Creek tragedy is all the more so because, only months earlier, in January of 2021, Enbridge drove sheet pilings  through an aquifer while trenching their pipeline near their own storage terminal at Clearbrook in Clearwater County. This happened when Enbridge was “surprised” by an already existing line in their path. Again driving pilings below their permitted depth, the company released over 50 million gallons of aquifer water into the surrounding landscape, endangering a calcareous fen, a type of wetland hosting rare and endangered species of plants that could be destroyed by a loss of aquifer pressure.

It was not until four months later, in the summer of 2021, that state regulators learned of the breach from independent volunteer monitors. Enbridge never revealed on their own the damage done at Clearbrook. By the summer of 2022, a year-and-a-half after the permit violations, a brute force “fix” similar to the one at La Salle Creek had failed to completely stop the flow.

Thirty days after the La Salle breach and adjacent to reservation land at Fond du Lac, Enbridge drove pilings into the wetlands and again breached the underlying aquifer.  This aquifer, it turns out, is an artesian aquifer under pressure. It literally burst from the ground. In documents shown to regulators, the company admitted being unfamiliar with the complex  hydrology of the area. The builder of the “most thoroughly studied” pipeline in state history did not know about the water geology at Fond du Lac before driving pilings 30 feet into the ground. Over 200 million gallons flowed out into the wetland forest threatening Deadfish Lake, an important ricing lake for the Fond du Lac Band.

Enbridge’s only accountability to Minnesota for its environmental damage and permit violations was a misdemeanor fine for taking water without a permit and a requirement to do extra environmental work in the pipeline corridor. Independent environmental monitors using thermal imaging and aerial drones have identified  at least 45 unreported places where subsurface aquifers continue releasing water to the surface as a result of construction activity. A year after completion, miles of silt fence and construction material remain in the corridor in violation of the permit.

Minnesota has become a mule for Canadian oil cartels and has sold a piece of itself to a foreign pipeline company that broke its promises and has not been held accountable for the damage it did. Our state regulators failed us, our land, and our water by permitting this project before it was adequately studied.

Take Action

A petition to hold Enbridge accountable can be found here: Demand Federal Agencies Hold Enbridge Accountable for Line 3 Destruction.

U.S. Minnesota Representative Betty McCollum is calling for a federal investigation of Enbridge violations and Minnesota’s regulatory failures. Her letter to the U.S. Corps of Engineers and the Environmental Protection Agency administrator can be found here.

More Information

• Final payout from the Enbridge Line 3 Public Safety Escrow Account: $8.5 million

• Healing Minnesota Stories: Enbridge Line 3

• Waadookawaad Amikwag/Those Who Help Beaver is an independent citizen science group powered entirely by volunteers and led by Indigenous values. A grassroots group of tribal members and citizen scientists came together in late 2021 as damages from the Enbridge Line 3 construction continued to emerge along the pipeline corridor.

• Honor the Earth-Stop Enbridge website

• Enbridge Line 3 Aquifer Breach explanation by Geologist Jeff Broberg

• La Salle Creek Aquifer Breach video

• Half of Line 3’s ‘Independent Environmental Monitors’ have prior work for Enbridge

• Minnesota Public Utilities Commission: MPUC Docket No. PL-6668/CN-13-473 OAH Docket NO. OAH-8-2500-31260; Direct Testimony of Paul Stolen (Friends of the Headwaters), November 19, 2014

• Minnesota Commerce Department Line 3 Replacement Docket Details

• Minnesota Public Utilities Commission Line 3 Web Page

• Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Line 3 Web Page

• Opening Panel – Findings from Waadookawaad Amikwag: Line 3 Destruction

John King is a long-time Land Stewardship Project member and is on board of the Land Stewardship Action Fund. He lives with his wife, Ruth, on 40 acres of mixed forest/pasture land in west-central Minnesota. They are looking for someone to share the land. King can be contacted at jfking353@gmail.com.

Category: Blog
Tags: corporate control • Enbridge Line 3 • Energy • extreme energy extraction • fossil fuels • green energy • oil pipelines • tar sands • water

Upcoming Events

×

June 2023

Saturday June 3

1:15 pm – 2:15 pm
Land Access & Leasing Options
Saturday June 3
1:15 pm – 2:15 pm
Land Access & Leasing Options

On Saturday, June 3, Wisconsin Farmers Unions will be holding a farm visit at Baldur Farm (N7659 950th St., River Falls,WI 54022) for landowners and renters looking to lease to the next generation of farmers.

Joyce Monari, a native of Kenya, has been growing two types of chinsaga, a type of green familiar to her people, for several years on Baldur Farm. She will show participants her garden, talk about her crops, and discuss the difficulty of finding land.

Juliet Tomkins and Prescott Bergh have rented land to a variety of farmers over the years, from beginning CSA growers to livestock operators. They will talk about their experiences, which have led to the contract they now use to ensure understanding between themselves and their renters before problems arise.

Light snacks and refreshments provided after the talks. Maureen and Rich, the farmers at Baldur Farm, will be on-hand to answer questions about their draft horses. Attendees are welcome to walk the farm trails.

For more information, contact the Farmers Union’s Maureen Ash at maureen7ash@gmail.com.

3:00 pm – 5:00 pm
Screening of Stewards of the Land / Serán las dueñas de la tierra in Northfield
Saturday June 3
3:00 pm – 5:00 pm
Screening of Stewards of the Land / Serán las dueñas de la tierra in Northfield

Stewards of the Land/Serán las dueñas de la tierrais a feature documentary about Stephanie, Ian, and Alfredo, three young landless ecological farmers in Puerto Rico striving to produce healthy food for local consumption.

In this economically depressed U.S. territory, producing food locally is urgent. The archipelago sits on the path of powerful hurricanes, an increasing threat as the climate crisis worsens. Puerto Rico is highly dependent on food imports and a third of its population lives food insecurity.

The story begins when the protagonists arrive for the first time on the public lands they rent. The farms have been abandoned for decades and lack the most basic infrastructure to get started. The story follows the protagonists as they struggle to get the farms running before and after powerful hurricanes devastate the archipelago. The documentary shows the protagonists’ grit as they attempt to carve a living without land ownership or capital.

There are two opportunities to participate:

  1. Clickhereto RSVP to the Northfield event on Saturday, June 3.
  2. Clickhereto RSVP to the Minneapolis event on Sunday, June 4; co-hosted with partner organization, Copal.Haz clic aquí para español.

Sunday June 4

3:00 pm – 5:00 pm
Screening of Stewards of the Land / Serán las dueñas de la tierra in Minneapolis
Sunday June 4
3:00 pm – 5:00 pm
Screening of Stewards of the Land / Serán las dueñas de la tierra in Minneapolis

Stewards of the Land/Serán las dueñas de la tierrais a feature documentary about Stephanie, Ian, and Alfredo, three young landless ecological farmers in Puerto Rico striving to produce healthy food for local consumption.

In this economically depressed U.S. territory, producing food locally is urgent. The archipelago sits on the path of powerful hurricanes, an increasing threat as the climate crisis worsens. Puerto Rico is highly dependent on food imports and a third of its population lives food insecurity.

The story begins when the protagonists arrive for the first time on the public lands they rent. The farms have been abandoned for decades and lack the most basic infrastructure to get started. The story follows the protagonists as they struggle to get the farms running before and after powerful hurricanes devastate the archipelago. The documentary shows the protagonists’ grit as they attempt to carve a living without land ownership or capital.

There are two opportunities to participate:

  1. Clickhereto RSVP to the Northfield event on Saturday, June 3.
  2. Clickhereto RSVP to the Minneapolis event on Sunday, June 4; co-hosted with partner organization, Copal.Haz clic aquí para español.

Tuesday June 6

11:00 am – 12:00 pm
Forever Green Winter Barley Webinar
Tuesday June 6
11:00 am – 12:00 pm
Forever Green Winter Barley Webinar

The Environmental & Economic Clusters of Opportunity (EECO) grant provides an ecosystem services payment as well as risk management payments to growers enrolled in the program for winter barley, hybrid winter rye, winter camelina, and Kernza. Join us for an introductory webinar series on these four crops where we pair University researchers and Extension professionals with farmers who have trialed these crops on-farm. The webinar on June 6 will be on winter barley and will feature Jochum Wiersma (UMN Extension small grains agronomist) and Kurt Kimber (farmer, Hampton, Minn.).

To sign-up for the June 6 webinar on winter barley, click here. These presentations will be recorded for future viewing if you’re not able to make it.

Wednesday June 7

11:00 am – 12:00 pm
Forever Green Webinar on Winter Camelina
Wednesday June 7
11:00 am – 12:00 pm
Forever Green Webinar on Winter Camelina

The Environmental & Economic Clusters of Opportunity (EECO) grant provides an ecosystem services payment as well as risk management payments to growers enrolled in the program for winter barley, hybrid winter rye, winter camelina, and Kernza. Join us for an introductory webinar series on these four crops where we pair University researchers and Extension professionals with farmers who have trialed these crops on-farm. On June 7, there will be a webinar on winter camelina. Presenters include Matthew Ott (UMN post doc researcher, camelina genetics) and Anne Schwagerl (farmer, Browns Valley, Minn.).

To sign-up for the June 7 webinar on winter camelina, click here. These presentations will be recorded for future viewing if you’re not able to make it.

View Full Calendar

Recent Posts

  • 2023 Minnesota Legislative Session Wrap-Up  May 25, 2023
  • Tell Lawmakers that Farmworkers Deserve Paid Family & Medical Leave May 3, 2023
  • 2023 Minnesota Legislative Session Update — 4 Weeks Left! April 25, 2023
  • It’s a Wrap: The Largest Family Farm Breakfast & Lobby Day in LSP History April 24, 2023
  • Tell Your MN House Member Today to Lower Prescription Drug Costs & Reject Poison Pill Amendments April 24, 2023

Montevideo

117 South First Street
Montevideo, MN 56265

(320) 269-2105

Lewiston

180 E. Main Street
Lewiston, MN 55952

(507) 523-3366

Minneapolis

821 E. 35th Street #200
Minneapolis, MN 55407

(612) 722-6377

  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2023 Land Stewardship Project. All rights reserved.

https://landstewardshipproject.org/line-3-environmental-damage-state-regulatory-failure